Review: Emma

The latest Jane Austen novel to get updated by the fine folks at The Austen Project is Emma. Acclaimed author Alexander McCall Smith was tapped to rewrite this novel for today's audience. I went in with the hope that I'd enjoy Emma more if she were modern. Nope. Still not a fan of that girl!

Here's the synopsis:

Prepare to meet a young woman who thinks she knows everything
Fresh from university, Emma Woodhouse arrives home in Norfolk ready to embark on adult life with a splash. Not only has her sister, Isabella, been whisked away on a motorbike to London, but her astute governess, Miss Taylor is at a loose end watching as Mr. Woodhouse worries about his girls. Someone is needed to rule the roost and young Emma is more than happy to oblige.
At the helm of her own dinner parties, and often found either rearranging the furniture at the family home of Hartfield, or instructing her new protegee, Harriet Smith, Emma is in
charge. You don’t have to be in London to go to parties, find amusement or make trouble.
Not if you’re Emma, the very big fish in the rather small pond.
But for someone who knows everything, Emma doesn’t know her own heart. And there is only one person who can play with Emma’s indestructible confidence, her friend and inscrutable neighbour George Knightly – this time has Emma finally met her match?
Ever alive to the social comedy of village life, beloved author Alexander McCall Smith’s Emma is the busybody we all know and love, and a true modern delight.

I first read Austen's Emma for a university film class. We had to read the book, watch the Gwyneth Paltrow adaptation, then Clueless, and finally write an essay. I seriously disliked it. It wasn't the writing or the time period - it was Emma herself. She's nosy and annoying and thinks she knows all. I was really hopeful that the updated Emma would be slightly less insufferable. No such luck. All of her frustrating qualities seem to transfer over to the modern age!

As with some of the other updates I've read, I didn't really think McCall Smith did a great job of modernizing the story. Granted, I imagine it would be kind of hard when one of the biggest storylines is Emma staying at home with her father and eventually falling in love with a much older man. Too much stays the same (why does Emma still have a governess in modern day England? Unless that's still a thing?) and that disappoints me.

This is, clearly, a short review but I just couldn't think of anything to say. (Why beat around the bush, eh?) I didn't enjoy Jane Austen's Emma and I certainly didn't enjoy Alexander McCall Smith's retelling. I don't think it did what The Austen Project wanted it to do...though I'm beginning to wonder what that is...please, oh please, don't let them butcher Pride and Prejudice, which is up next. 

*A copy of this novel was provided by the publisher, Random House of Canada, in exchange for review consideration. All opinions are honest and my own.*

Review: Trains and Lovers

Trains and Lovers was my first Alexander McCall Smith novel, if you can believe it. It seems like I've always been aware of him but I just never read any of his books. I had mixed feelings going into this one as I have always heard great things of him but I hadn't heard rave reviews of this book. Turns out I still have mixed feelings! The book was alright but it wasn't anything all that special.

Here's the synopsis:

The rocking of the train car, the sound of its wheels on the rails...there's something special about this form of travel that makes for easy conversation. Which is just what happens to the four strangers who meet in Trains and Lovers. As they travel by rail from Edinburgh to London, they entertain one another with tales of how trains have changed their lives. A young, keen-eyed Scotsman recounts how he turned a friendship with a young woman co-worker into a romance by spotting an anachronistic train in an 18th-century painting. An Australian woman shares how her parents fell in love and spent their life together running a railroad siding in the remote Australian Outback. A middle-aged American arts patron sees 2 young men saying goodbye in the station and recalls his youthful crush on another man. And a young Englishman describes how exiting his train at the wrong station allowed him to meet an intriguing woman whom he impulsively invited to dinner--and into his life.

I liked the idea of the story. I think everyone's probably struck up a conversation with a stranger before simply because of proximity. In the case of this train journey, the characters had their destination in common and an intimate conversation sprung from that. I like the idea of being able to tell a story to complete strangers that you may not tell your friends. There's something a little freeing about that. It's not that these characters are giving away their darkest secrets but they don't have to worry about any preconceived notions that they would have with friends.

I think my problem was that the stories did not have equal weight in my head while I was reading the book. I was most interested in Andrew's story and always wanted the focus to go back to him whenever another character was telling their story. Perhaps it's because he was really the first that we're introduced to and the first to speak in the train car or perhaps it's just because I liked his story the most. I suspect it's a combination of the two. David's story, the middle-aged American, just seemed like a throwaway and it didn't stick with me. Kay, the Australian woman, had an interesting historical story but I wished it had been her story, not her parent's. Finally, the Englishman, Hugh, doesn't get a chance to tell his story until well past halfway through the book. I suppose it makes sense that it was unbalanced because this way everyone gets their chance to tell their full story during their trip but I just wish it the stories were told in a slightly different way.

Trains and Lovers was a really fast read at 240 pages (it's also a small book, not your average hardcover size). Even though I didn't love it, it hasn't turned me off reading more of Alexander McCall Smith. I'd like to see what some of his other novels are like before deciding whether or not I like his writing. I'd recommend this novel if you're looking for a quick read that will make you think about the people you meet and what their stories are.

*I received a copy of this novel from the publisher, Random House of Canada, in exchange for an honest review.*